waking lazarus
news and reviews
downloads
press kit
special offers
contacts and questions
the other side


..............................

..............................

ARCHIVES October 2007 • September 2007 • July 2007 • June 2007 • April 2007 • February 2007 • January 2007 • December 2006 • November 2006 • October 2006 • September 2006 • August 2006 • July 2006 • June 2006 • May 2006 • April 2006 • March 2006 • February 2006 • January 2006 • December 2005 • November 2005 • October 2005 • September 2005 • August 2005 • July 2005 • June 2005 • May 2005 • April 2005 • March 2005 • February 2005 • January 2005 • December 2004 • November 2004 • September 2004 • August 2004 • July 2004 • June 2004 • April 2004 • March 2004 • February 2004 • January 2004 • December 2003 • November 2003 • October 2003 • September 2003 • August 2003 •
..............................

FEED ME
Atom • RSS 1.0 • RSS 2.0 • RSD • FeedBurner

..............................

POWERED BY
Movable Type 3.21

..............................

THE DEAD WHISPER ON
The new book by T.L. Hines
The new single by Pivitplex
..............................

JOIN MY MAILING LIST
Win a $15 Gift Card.
..............................

VIDEO PREVIEWS


..............................

..............................

AUTHOR PHOTOS BY CELIA MANGUS

January 20, 2004
CNN vs. Fox News: Same News, Different Stories?

On the right side of the cable news aisle, we have the folks at Fox News, who trumpet their ’Äúfair and balanced’Äù coverage. On the left side, we have CNN, preferred by people who are likely to refer to Fox News as ’ÄúFaux News.’Äù

Is reporting on CNN too liberal? Is reporting on Fox News too conservative? Well, let’Äôs put it to the test, using last night’Äôs coverage of John Kerry’Äôs win in the Iowa caucuses as an example.

On CNN, Judy Woodruff and other correspondents discussed the caucus results immediately after Kerry’Äôs speech to supporters:

JUDY WOORUFF: ... I should say, how much the personal story of John Kerry has come into play in this campaign in the last few weeks. Jeff just talked about it. He has talked about his experience in Vietnam. We've met not one but two men whose lives John Kerry saved during the war in Vietnam. This, and the fact that he's so much more comfortable now talking about his experiences in Vietnam, his life, all of that, I think, has helped bring a shape, a human, and obviously a successful shape to this campaign...
BILL SCHNEIDER, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: ... John Kerry is a very formidable debater. He had a series of debates with Bill Weld when he faced reelection for the Senate. It was one of the great series of debates in American history. You just wait until George Bush gets into a debate with John Kerry, if John Kerry's the nominee.

Translation: Kerry is pure gold, baby, and a hell of a lot smarter than that idiot Bush from Texas.

At this point, I flipped the channel to Fox News (I have to paraphrase this, because I've yet to find a transcript):

FOX NEWS CORRESPONDENT (I’Äôm not certain who to attribute this to): Kerry’Äôs campaign was in real trouble. In fact, many people in the New England states were coming out against him after strong early support, so he had to go to Iowa and hope for something to happen. Tonight’Äôs results may show Kerry isn’Äôt as bad as they thought.

Translation: Kerry is a big loser whose campaign was on its last legs, but this Iowa campaign means he’Äôs not a TOTAL loser. Yet.

Show me which of these stories is ’Äúunfair,’Äù and I’Äôll show you where you are on the political spectrum.

In my view, both convey something true and newsworthy, even though both also have an obvious slant. And here’Äôs my real question: what’Äôs wrong with that? I like to see the news sifted through two opposing filters. Sorry to say, but ALL news is subject to the biases--conscious or unconscious--of the people writing and delivering said stories. And you know what? I wouldn’Äôt have it any other way, because watching a dry recitation of headlines would be as boring as watching John Kerry’Äôs ’ÄúThank You’Äù speech on television last night.

Whoops. Guess my bias slipped out there.

Posted by TLHines at January 20, 2004 01:31 PM